The NIMBY vs. Human rights argument has been front and centre in recent months concerning both the specific location of Charlton Hall, and the overall validity of the Hamilton bylaw designed to keep multiple residential care facilities from ‘ghettoizing’ neighbourhoods. While a balance is still yet to be struck in that debate, the Hamilton Wentworth District School Board (HWDSB) has settled a similar issue of their own.
Last week, in a Committee of the Whole meeting, they voted to strike down a menace that has been right in the middle of the Ainslie Wood neighbourhood for decades. In spite of all the protesting from the PIMBY (Please In My Back Yard) crowd, the Board narrowly eaked out a victory. Prince Philip School will close, ensuring that West Hamilton may finally be able to shed its ugly label as an “education ghetto”.
School buses will be employed to bring the hundreds of former Prince Philip students to George R. Allan school. In support of this victory, Board Chairman and Ward 3 Trustee Tim Simmons said: “busing to school longer distances hardens the kids up and makes them grow up a bit quicker”. Parents say this will be good for their soft, helpless 4-year olds who should really be sucking it up and taking the bus like the rest of us. One parent complained “The whining is already starting! ‘But Mommy my legs are too short to climb the stairs on the bus!’. I finally just had to throw his PB&J and Visa card into his brief case and send him out to pick up my dry cleaning. I couldn’t take the aggravation”
We interviewed another parent: “This is fantastic news! For years I’ve been begging the Board to let me ship my boys to a school on the other side of Main and King Streets. There’s nothing like dodging 8 lanes of speeding traffic twice a day to put some hair on your chest”. Another parent, equally excited about the news added: “I’m so glad I voted for Judith Bishop, a woman who has the good sense to completely ignore logic, hard data and the opinions of the vast majority of her constituents so she can do what executives who live in Burlington and Oakville think is right”.
Citizens have also long argued that access to public services across Hamilton has not always been equal. More rural areas have had the benefit of school buses for years. It looks like Ainslie Wood, a more densely populated, well-established neighbourhood, will finally be able to catch up to the more progressive and avant-garde areas like Greensville and Rockton.
This is also being hailed as a great victory for anti-poverty activists who insist that Hamilton needs more affordable housing. By removing the school from this well-established neighbourhood, hundreds of homes will almost instantly become more available to those who previously couldn’t afford to move into such a nice area of the City. The exodus of young families will also allow locals to realize their long-time goal of increasing conversions of single family homes into student housing.
It seems that unlike the contentious situation at Charlton House, through the hard work of Trustees and Board Staff, this story seems to be good news for everyone involved.




